Posted Posted on 2011-03-06
The refrain from an old popular song goes as follows, “What the world needs now is love sweet love, it’s the only thing that there’s just too little of…” According to Nicholas Kristof, in his recent New York Times editorial, Is Islam The Problem?, the Muslim world doesn’t need more love. It needs more banks, corporations and massive concentrations of wealth.
Referencing Dr. Timur Kumar’s study of Muslim economic stagnation, Kristof concludes that it is not Islam as such that is responsible for the economic stagnation of the Muslim world, rather certain stultifying Muslim business laws that have stifled the creation of the gargantuan financial institutions that are responsible for the economic prowess of the West.
It is interesting that Kristof would deliver this particular broadside at Islam at time when the Western nations are reeling from the debilitating influences of an ill-conceived financial system that is spiraling wildly out of control. Banks and the related financial “services” industry have orchestrated the greatest upward shift of wealth in human history. Ordinary citizens have had their pension accounts raided, their savings looted (remember the S&L scandal of the 1980s), and the equity sucked out of their homes by a set of business practices that would have led to the mass incarceration of the perpetrators in a just society.
Entire countries like Iceland have been rendered financially insolvent, while thieves in suits and ties walk out of national treasuries with billions of dollars in tax-payers money. Perhaps Kristof has not taken time to watch the Oscar-winning documentary, Inside Job, a brilliant expose on the current fiscal crisis. If he had, I think he might realize that this is not the ideal historical moment to be pontificating about the virtue of the banking industry, monopolies and corporations.
Speaking of corporations, Kristof argues that in the Muslim world they did not assume the colossal size they have reached in the West owing to the nature of the laws governing business partnerships in Islam. What he fails to mention is that that the huge dimensions of western corporations have allowed them to orchestrate a de facto take over of our political system, to plunder the world’s resources and despoil the natural environment.
In terms of environmental degradation, consider another documentary, Gasland, which was nominated for an Oscar. It shows just how nefarious the resource extraction corporations can be. Led by that exemplar of the virtue of western corporate ethics, Haliburton, those industries are in the process of destroying aquifers all over this country through the process of hydraulic fracturing (fracking). This film documents the influence of corporations, not only on our environment, but also on the political system as their lobbyists buy off politicians and manipulate the media to serve their sole interest -profits. Is this what the Muslim world needs more of if it is to prosper and create the just and equitable socieites protesters in Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and elsewhere are dreaming of? I would think not.
Kristof concludes with his hope that the current uprisings in the Middle East can address the issue of “what went wrong” in the Muslim world by creating the conditions for a new beginning. In light of the destructive impact of the banking industry, corporations and the huge concentration of wealth in the hands of an ever-shrinking few here in the West, the question of “what went wrong” is indeed appropriate. However, it is being hurled in the wrong direction.
We need to be asking what went wrong in the West, generally, and here in America, specifically. How is it that billionaires are not proportionately taxed and poor people end up having services they have paid for such as social security threatened, while those same billionaires are paid interest on the money they have “loaned” the government with tax dollars taken from the poor? How is it that private, corporate military contractors with a vested economic interest in the perpetuation of war are being paid billions of dollars to do things the military used to do for free, or at a fraction of the cost? How is it that a nation with 5% of the world’s population has half all its incarcerated individuals and corporate prisons are paying millions of dollars to judges to sentence teenagers to jail?
This is just the tip of the iceberg of what has gone wrong in this country, and role of the banks and corporations in those developments. Yet the best Kristof can do is to point a patronizing finger at the Muslims and tell them their countries need more of what is destroying ours. As the Qur’an rhetorically asks, “What is wrong with you? How is it that you judge?”
Kristof is right about one thing in his article. Namely, that a new day is indeed dawning in the Muslim world and that new day gives the Muslims a chance to do things differently. However, that new day also gives America a chance to do things differently in the Muslim world. She can open a new era in her relations with the Muslim world, an era based on mutual cooperation, mutual respect and a collective effort to work towards the betterment of world for all of its inhabitants. She can also choose to continue to walk clumsily and to carry a big stick. Kristof seems to prefer the latter choice as the big stick approach has always been one that has sought to bludgeon the natives into submission in order to clear the way for the banks, corporations and filthy concentrations of wealth that Kristof seems so enthralled by. Kristof’s time in Cairo should alert him to a very sobering reality. The big stick approach does not command the fear it once did.
To return to the song, “What the world needs now is love sweet love, no not just for some but for everyone…”
As-salaam alaikum Imam Zaid, brilliant article masha-Allah! However it's sad that at this moment of such incredible change going on in the Arab world the American government decides upon this 'Salem witch trials' of Peter King! It does not bode well, and is very telling of what this government really thinks of the 'Arab awakening'!
Kristof doesn't condemn Islam; he discusses possible reasons for the perceived backwardness of some predominately Islamic countries. He asks, 'Is Islam the problem?' thereby opening the topic for discussion. An old tactic for not answering the problem as presented, is to turn it back on the questioner. This issue is not about America, but about Islamically dominated countries. America is only a few hundred years old; the problems Kristof discusses began thousands of years ago. If your solution to political, cultural and economic problems in those countries is 'more love', I can only shake my head in amazement because I know you to be a well-educated, thoughtful individual. We would all be better served if you would address the questions posed, and provide some version of suggested solutions.
bismillah, alhumdulillah.salaat and salaams to our beloved sayidna nabi mohammad saws. May Allah swt protect imam zaid shakir, for speaking the truth, ma shah ALLAH
salaam with respect i think that if you are going to introduce to the work of Dr Tamir Kuran to the readers you do need to come up with a better defence for traditional Islam. The fact that the banks are going through a bad time doesn't prove that they havent "orchestrated the greater upward shift in in wealth in the history of the world". Capitalism based on large instituions is doing very well in the BRIC countries and many people are glad to leave subsistence lifestlye and enjoy the ease that tecnologies such as refigeration brings to them, If we approve of the social upheaval that is going on in the middle east we cant leave large corperations out of the picture. One of the key hero was an employee of google. The mobile phone, the computer all were developed through bank financing. It was "greedy" industrailist that built the factories which employed blacks in the nineteenth century. Can we leave factories out of the equation when we talk about the civil war and subsequent emancipation of the slaves. Can the automobile and bus be erased from picture of the civil rights movement in the 60,s? these are not easy questions and they are questions ive been grappling with for a long time. I was brought up in the 70,s in the house of left wing pollitcal activists against nuclear power and male dominated corperations and then became engrossed in the green movement. I then found Islam traveled a lot and saw that basically people want a western stlye of life based upon tecnological advancements. Any way to put it simply in my case the jury is still out and i dont expect to see them for some time.
the more i think about your post the more i agree. the book by Timor Kuran could just as well be called "why the nuclear bomb wasn't made in islamic society" Islam empowers women who humanise society. The type of patriarchal society devoleped in european societies because of unjust inheritence laws and usary created tryrant divorced from humanity ready to carry out injustices such as the African slave trade. Science became an dehumanising force supporting male patriarchy. yes what the world need is more love and that can come by empowering good women in the way islam always has
As-Salaam Alaykum Imam Zaid, I would highly recommend that you withdraw this posting. If I was grading this as a student's paper, it would receive a "D" at best It appears that instead of actually reading the article "Is Islam The Problem?" by Nicholas Kristof you instead just read the title and wrote an emotional response to the title. Nichols Kritoff repeatedly defends Islam in the article but tries to offer an answer to the very question that perplexes so many , both inside and outside of Islam. Why did the Muslim world fall to such depths after being so more advanced and developed than the western world was 500 to 1000 years ago. You never once even addressed this central question in your article. Your article is more in line with what one would have expected to hear on Radio Moscow as a socialist or communist diatribe attacking the USA and capitalism; this is not what I expect from you or from any student of Sheikh Al-Shaghouri. You can do better.
its always difficult to identifies what want wrong and when.. But i am also looking for this what went wrong..
The more I think about it, the more it hits me that the Islamic nation is just a loving, peaceful religion, I really don't know why some people think they are bad just because some terrorists. Sometimes even then <a href="http://www.pauldavisrestoration.org/">paul davis restoration</a> helps them when they are in need
Just try to visit this <a href="http://bidbass.com">Bidbass - Penny Auction.</a> . For more information.
I was lucky to find this www.newislamicdirections.com web site. You truly can write and teach and inspire. Keep writing - I'll keep reading.
In every country, there will consistently be botheration and risks.Even if you alive in a superpower country, the bread-and-butter crisis is article that can't be avoided. So bodies should accept alertness about this. accident helpline
Islam is the best way of life. When we hold our way of life, all problem will resolve soon. When we go far away from Islam, problem will come.
We hold Islam dear to our heart.
very intresting views thanks alot keep them coming.
Very interesting and informative post. <a href="http://www.inexpensive-health-insurance.info/">Inexpensive Health Insurance</a>
I would highly recommend that you withdraw this posting. If I was grading this as a student’s paper, it would receive a “D” at best It appears that instead of actually reading the article “Is Islam The Problem?” by Nicholas Kristof you instead just read the title and wrote an emotional response to the title. Nichols Kritoff repeatedly defends Islam in the article but tries to offer an answer to the very question that perplexes so many , both inside and outside of Islam.
It was “greedy” industrylist that built the factories which employed blacks in the nineteenth century. Can we leave factories out of the equation when we talk about the civil war and subsequent emancipation of the slaves. Can the automobile and bus be erased from picture of the civil rights movement in the 60,s? these are not easy questions and they are questions I've been grappling with for a long time. I was brought up in the 70,s in the house of left wing pollitical activists against nuclear power and male dominated corporations and then became engrossed in the green movement. I then found Islam traveled a lot and saw that basically people want a western style of life based upon technological advancements. Any way to put it simply in my case the jury is still out and i don't expect to see them for some time.
Don't you acknowledge that it's high time to receive the <a href="http://bestfinance-blog.com">loans</a>, which would realize your dreams.
This is an excellent post. Thanks for share your informative information with all. iPhone
College students have to understand that the good <a href="http://primeessays.com/index.php?mode=buy-essays-online">buy essays online</a> service will aid to reach a success, composing the perfect quality critical essay. Therefore, it's your own selection to buy custom essays or to spend days for essays composing!
Students that are searching for some knowledge about <a href="http://bestwritingservice.com/write-my-paper.html">write my paper</a> at the <a href="http://www.bestwritingservice.com">custom writing</a> service can read through your fantastic knowledge referring to this good topic. In other case, it
Simply desire to say your article is as amazing. The clarity in your post is simply spectacular and i could assume you are an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission let me to grab your RSS feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please continue the rewarding work.
Hi. Cool post. There's an issue with your web site in firefox, and you may want to check this... The browser is the marketplace chief and a good element of other people will pass over your wonderful writing due to this problem.
Hey. Cool article. There is an issue with the website in chrome, and you may want to test this... The browser is the marketplace chief and a good part of people will omit your fantastic writing because of this problem.
Hi. Neat article. There is an issue with the website in firefox, and you may want to check this... The browser is the market chief and a good component to folks will leave out your great writing because of this problem.
Hey. Neat post. There is a problem with the website in internet explorer, and you might want to test this... The browser is the market chief and a huge component to other folks will leave out your fantastic writing due to this problem.
I think that you want to get know about this post and <a href="http://exclusivepapers.com">essay writing</a>. At the essay writing services it is not very hard to buy research papers or <a href="http://exclusivepapers.com">custom essays</a> reffering to this post.
It is in point of fact a nice and useful piece of info. I
Information is power and now I'm a !@#$ing dctiaotr.
Appreciate the great website. I like your current design and style. In terms of how People in america view President Obama commencing the brand new calendar year, there appears to be hardly any spirit regarding Auld Lang Syne. Rather, in line with the new California Whispers poll, many voters aren’t disregarding what you don't like about Barack obama and need your pet from place of work <a >writers service</a>. In your Fresh Year’s study, whenever questioned just what media event they fear the majority of regarding 2012, Americans with a margin involving two-to-one explained Obama’s reelection. Only Sixteen % mentioned these people fear your Democrat won’t acquire a second phrase, while Thirty three percent said that they fear 4 a lot more many years.
Hey there! I just like the common sense and thinking of the writer. Fantastic to observe such ideas talked over on the website. You actually really need to motivate guest interaction and dialogue <a href="http://www.magicessays.com">Buy Term Papers</a>. Stick to the great work!
Very good material. Many thanks for your internet site. Just a recommendation. I'm not really marketing Google at all, but I have noticed that you're not making use of Google Analytics on your internet site. That is a fantastic way to enhance your site and monetize it in a more efficient manner. It really allows to track visits and see exactly what particular information is most liked. I suggest it. One other essential software system for that purpose is PIWIK and it's an open source free of charge program that you deploy on your web hosting service account <a href="http://www.royalessays.com">Custom Writing</a>
Wonderful blog post. The visual content presented right here is of pretty great quality. I most certainly will use this web site much more often regarding <a href="http://www.ipillion.com">ban ip address</a>
I like the valuable info you supply for your articles. I’ll bookmark your weblog and take a look at again here regularly. I'm moderately sure I will be informed lots of new stuff right here! Good luck for the following! <a >auto insurance quotes</a> <a >auto insurance</a>
That is a totally very nice material written here. I thank you for good content material. I 'm writing a research paper about politics and your internet site aided a good deal. I am a school student and if you are in a deficiency of time I strongly suggest to get help regarding <a href="http://www.my-writing-service.com">Custom Essays</a>. Cheers!
I appreciate your article just about this good post. I wanted say that I didn’t notice such kind of good thesis writer until this time. Can you write the very good <a href="http://www.topthesis.com">thesis</a> and example of thesis?
RWHtHk I really enjoy the post.Really thank you! Really Cool.
Good write-up. Terrific thoughts shared. Appreciate your website. <a href="http://www.solidwriters.com/buy_a_dissertation">Buy dissertation</a> Best of luck.
Your images are fantastic. I adore the content, it continues to keep your readers linked to your site. I'm a scholar and i'm right now filled with term papers, <a href="http://www.solidwriters.com/cheap_dissertation">cheap dissertation writer</a> research papers, book reports essays papers and other projects. I really want to compose my very own works nevertheless some guide is often desired. I will make use of solidwriters.com for my own final buy dissertation project . I recently found them through google search . Can keep you submitted on the outcomes.
I wish to give thanks to you with regard to your webpage. You've gotten lots of unique stuff for that reason the site is valuable. I'm a university student in Cali and I currently have an critical school assignment due in the week. I'm really cornered as well as currently have writers-block right now as I am investigating. Simply need anyone to assist me modify the cost-free article I recently found using the net <a href="http://www.customessaymeister.com/customessays/Arts: Music/1576.htm">tupac shakur: the meaning of the words essay</a>. That document satisfies my specifications nevertheless is composed in an undesirable fashion and there are grammar mistakes. Do you reckon I ought to proceed? Now i'm just desperate for help, thus almost any advice could be good.
I'd like to give thanks to you pertaining to your site. You have got quite a lot of remarkable resources for that reason the site is very helpful. I'm a student in San diego and I have got an crucial school assignment scheduled now. I am just frozen as well as get writers block for the time being as I am studying. Simply need a person to assist me revise the cost-free article I stumbled upon on the web <a href="http://www.customessaymeister.com/customessays/Labor Studies/9003.htm">child labor in pakistan essay</a>. That report suits my personal specifications nevertheless is authored in a poor fashion and there are syntax blunders. Do you consider I should proceed? Now i'm simply just eager for help, therefore any kind of advice might be wonderful.
Keep posting stuff like this i really like it</PostText>
Hello there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it is truly informative. I am gonna watch out for brussels. I'll be grateful if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers! It's appropriate time to make some plans for the future and it's time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I want to suggest you some interesting things or suggestions <a >how to unlock iphone 5 baseband 02.10.05</a> <a href="http://unlockiphone5steps.com">unlock phones</a>
As I web site possessor I believe the subject material here is rattling great , appreciate it for your efforts. PoIuYt
Good write up! I am gonna watch out for brussels. I’ll be grateful if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers! It’s appropriate time to make some plans for the future and it’s time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I want to suggest you some interesting things or suggestions. Thanks.
Great effort! I appreciate this type of job. Really i was looking forward to read about it. love this entry. Thanks for this allocation. :lol: <a href="http://www.joshbd.com/">cheap web hosting</a>
Ha, very impressive post! I love this topic is being so funny I should ask. Thanks for write up! :)
Great effort! I appreciate this type of job. Really i was looking forward to read about it. love this entry. Thanks for this allocation. :lol:
Hello Imam Zaid!! This article is really worth reading. Whatever shared here about new Islamic directories seems like meaningful advices. I'm very pleased by acknowledging some great knowledge about Islam from here. Thanks and keep up this good sharing.
Howdy, i read your blog from time to time and i own a similar one and i was just curious if you get a lot of spam responses? If so how do you reduce it, any plugin or anything you can recommend? I get so much lately it's driving me insane so any support is very much appreciated.
I think your suggestion would be helpful for me. I will let you know if its work for me too. Thanks and keep posting such an informative blogs.
I truly love your site.. Very nice colors & theme. Did you create this web site yourself? Please reply back as I'm looking to create my own personal blog and would like to find out where you got this from or what the theme is named. Kudos!