New Islamic Directions

By Imam Zaid Shakir

Bravo Egypt!

Posted in articles by Imam Zaid Shakir on 2011-02-11 Thumb

The Egyptian people have accomplished one of the major objectives of their historic revolution. They have brought the thirty-year reign of Hosni Mubarak to an end. As they celebrate, from Alexandria in the north down to Aswan in the south, they realize that this is only the beginning of the long and arduous march to a free and open system that will guarantee their dignity and fundamental rights. However, every journey has a beginning and this glorious beginning is a harbinger of a glorious end. As the great Egyptian sage, Ibn ‘Ata Allah Sankadari, mentioned, “An illuminated beginning is a portent of an illuminated end.” May that be so in the case of the Egyptian Revolution.

The size and strategic position of Egypt, her central place in America’s geostrategic planning, her historical leadership of the Arab world and the sheer magnitude of the security “apparatus” that the people had to overcome to reach this point will ensure that the ongoing revolution will be deeply studied by many for decades to come. Here are some of my reflections on the revolution thus far.

First of all, I do not write these lines as someone unfamiliar with Egyptian society. Upon completing my graduate studies in 1986 I departed for a year of Arabic studies in Cairo. As a poor student with only the irregular salary from my part-time job as an English teacher at the ‘Aziz Billah Mosque in the Zaytoun section of Cairo, I ate what my neighbors ate, namely a steady diet of Ful and Ta’miyya sandwiches, supplemented by pickled turnips. I slept on the floor of the masjid with my brothers during my Ramadan retreat. And I rode the crowded buses, becoming adept at grabbing the pole and jumping into the backdoor of those constantly moving, diesel-belching wrecks.

I also had an opportunity to become familiar with the expansive reach of the secret police, the Mukhabarat. One day while walking to one of my classes, I was offered a “taxi” ride to the mosque where the class was being held. In my then broken Arabic and through pointing I indicated that the mosque was only two blocks away. The driver and the passenger in the front seat insisted that they take me to the Mosque. I was adamant in my insistence that I walk the remaining distance. Finally, one of them flashed a badge and demanded that I get in the car. Upon doing so, I was bombarded with a barrage of questions asking what I was doing in Cairo, did I know this or that Muslim personality, where was I really going, etc. Finally, convinced that I was just a student from America they let me go, but not before rifling through my briefcase and helping themselves to a few “souvenirs.”

I was allowed to go on to my destination, but for far too many Egyptians, their “taxi rides” ended on the “dark side.” I had the opportunity to get first hand descriptions of that “dark side” by talking to many Egyptians who had been in the “Zinzanah,” the torture cells of the regime. They spoke of the beatings, the cigarette burns, the dogs, and other horrors they had experienced directly or witnessed. This is part of the reality that contributed to the revolution that has succeeded in ousting Hosni Mubarak.

In the events leading up to and now culminating with Mubarak’s resignation there are accusations, such as that articulated in an editorial in the Israeli daily, Haaretz, that Obama will go down in history for losing Egypt. This sentiment succinctly expresses the deep, dehumanizing racism that has driven the policy of supporting authoritarian dictators in the Middle East. These paternalistic tyrants will keep their “children” in their “place” to protect foreign interests. The same racist sentiment also drives the idea of Muslim “exceptionalism.” Muslims in the Middle East, we were told, are too irresponsible, reckless or just plain undeserving of governing themselves.

The people of Egypt have shown that they are not the property of any foreign power to be owned, used, abused and then discarded or possibly “lost.” They are human, men and women determined to carve out a dignified existence for themselves and their progeny. In so doing, they have shattered, to this point, virtually every myth and stereotype encouraging Americans to view Muslims as our inherent enemies. For example, we have been told that Muslims are bloodthirsty savages. We have been told that political Islam is a totalitarian system that knows of no compromise. Yet in Egypt, as in Tunisia, we have seen a majority Muslim population engage in a nonviolent revolution. The Muslim ideologues in the movement, including the Muslim Brotherhood, have cooperated with their Christian and secular fellow citizens aspiring to a new Egypt, not as a domineering and condescending force, but as full partners.The youth have been universally recognized as the visionaries who expanded the realm of the politically possible. Finally, women have been accepted as equal if not surpassing agents of change -the heroine of the revolution is a brave and defiant woman, Asmaa Mahfuz, whose youtube appeal was critical in the success of the pivotal January 25, 2011 mobilization. All of these characteristics make the Egyptian revolution one of the great sociopolitical developments of this new century.

Here in the United States many politicians and pundits are asking, “Why didn’t we see this coming?” I will offer my answer here. Specifically, American policy-making towards the Middle East has become dominated by anti-Muslim bigots. They have projected their own fears onto the governing elite and created such an obsession with so-called radical Islam that the latter has accepted the draconian (and profitable for some) measures being put into place to fight it, including support for “moderate” regimes like Mubarak’s. All the while, they have failed to take note of the real, dynamic politics on the ground in the Middle East and the civil society that has sprung up around those politics. The Egyptian Revolution has shown just how weak and marginal so-called radical Islam is in most Muslim societies. In one of the great ironies of history, the violent nihilists of “radical Islam,” besides the army, represent one of the few potential counter-revolutionary forces in Egypt.

The road ahead in Egypt will not be an easy one. There are powerful interests, both in Egypt and in other countries who were profiting lavishly from the ancien regime and the system of crony capitalism it has put in place to syphon off the country’s wealth. They have much to lose from a new system and will fight hard to preserve at least some of the privileges they formerly possessed. New institutions will have to be built. A new balance of power will have to be hammered out between the groups the protesters represent and the older, more established parties and groups who supported the protests, along with those who did not. The healthcare and university systems, both of which have been destroyed by mindless and neglectful policies, will have to be rebuilt. The minefields of the Palestinian situation will also have to be traversed.  However, that is tomorrow’s work and tomorrow’s worry. As for today, let the people of Egypt celebrate. Bravo, Egypt, Bravo!


By Rowda on February 12, 2011 at 8:07am

Thank you Imam Zaid for so eloquently expressing the concern, solidarity and pride that we have all been feeling as we've watched brave Egyptians take on and defeat oppression. May Allah protect them all as they embark on the next phase of this inspiring and humbling journey.

By Zaynab on February 12, 2011 at 12:53pm

May Allah Most Exalted bless the people of Egypt with wise, pious leaders and the strength to move forward in the coming days. The powers that be do not want to see a free, sovereign Arab nation that is inspired by Islamic values. May Allah Ta'ala protect Egypt and help her to deal with her friends with compassion and enemies with justice.

By Wael - on February 12, 2011 at 1:12pm

A deeply insightful analysis, thank you. It's a historic and thrilling day for Egypt, one I've been waiting for for a long time. My hope is that Egypt will become free, with freedom of speech and assembly, free political parties, and human rights reform. I'd like to see Egypt become a beacon of light for all of the Arab world and Africa as well. This has been a unique revolution in so many ways, really a revolution of the 21st century. One lesson is that when people have information, and can communicate, they are empowered. In the Information Age it may be impossible for repressive governments to keep their people in the dark and to conceal their crimes.

By Farah Abid on February 12, 2011 at 6:03pm

Beautiful article! I loved it!

By ImamZ on February 13, 2011 at 5:21am

Salam, Thank you for writing this, far too many 'traditional' sunni ulama are finding themselves on the wrong side of what happened in Egypt. They are holding onto the age old sunni doctrine of accepting whatever a ruler does, no matter how devious he is as long as he is outwardly a 'Muslim'. This has been a bane on Sunni Islam, and indeed in Egypt the traditional Sunni ulema (as well as traditional Copt hierarchy) have by in large marginalized themselves. Zaidiya

By st on March 1, 2011 at 11:12am

You have a great way to write, and I think there is allot of truth in it. Will be reading more of you blog, and I like the design to :)

By Matt the best sink garbage disposal guy on March 8, 2011 at 8:47pm

Great article. I think there is a lot of mis-understanding when it comes to middle eastern countries where the islamic religion is prevalent. Thanks for shedding some light on Egypts current situation.

By alexfrg on May 26, 2011 at 5:41am

Salam, i think it is a great revolution from the Egyptian in this 21st Century timeline. And it is now a peaceful time to travel to Egypt.

By Buy an Essay on January 17, 2012 at 11:36am

Howdy ! I personally just like the sense and thought process of the actual author. Terrific to view such ideas discussed on the world wide web. You certainly ought to stimulate website visitor interaction and discussion <a href="">Custom Research Paper</a>. Keep up the wonderful work!

By custom research papers on January 31, 2012 at 12:23am

Fantastic material. Thank you for your internet site. A little tip. I'm not really marketing Google in the slightest, but I have seen that you are not making use of Google Analytics on your web page. That is a good way to increase your site and generate income from it in a more effective way. It actually enables to keep track of visits and discover precisely what distinct content material is very popular. I strongly suggest it. Another great software application for that goal is PIWIK in fact it is an open source free of charge package that you deploy on your own web hosting account <a href="">Custom Term Papers</a>

By SuperDumb on February 4, 2012 at 6:53am

Fantastic blog post. The visual material displayed right here is of really high quality. I'm going to take this internet site more often regarding <a href="">ip address to location</a>

By Online writing service on February 10, 2012 at 3:40pm

That is some excellent information written here. I appreciate your fantastic content material. I 'm writing a research paper regarding national healthcare and your site aided a great deal. I am a higher education university student and if you are in a absence of time I recommend to find support for <a href="">Custom Term Paper</a>. Cheers!

By accident claim on April 8, 2012 at 3:56am

I found out your website page from google and it truly is pretty informative. Hey Thank you for writing this kind of an informative blog post. road traffic accident claims accident claims

By Dissertation Writing Approved by Turnitin on April 15, 2012 at 12:41pm

Your images are superb. I adore the article content, it gets your online visitors fastened to your weblog. I'm a scholar and I am right now filled with term papers, <a href="">thesis writers</a> research papers, book reports essays papers and other projects. I really want to generate my very own works but some aid is often desired. I intend to work with for my final buy dissertation challenge . I came across them by means of google . Will keep you posted on the effects.

By TimurDumb on April 16, 2012 at 9:51pm

I have to give thanks to you pertaining to your site. You've gotten plenty of interesting resources for that reason the site is worth finding out about. I'm a university student in Cali and I have got an essential term paper due in the week. Now i am having trouble as well as have writers-block for the time being as I am investigating. Only need somebody to assist me modify the cost-free article I came across on the internet <a href=" Testing/6903.htm">animal abuse essay</a>. That report matches my personal requirements nevertheless is written in an awful fashion and there are sentence structure mistakes. Do you think I should proceed? I'm just desperate for aid, therefore almost any suggestion might be good.

By web hosting on July 11, 2012 at 2:19am

Oh really I got some excellent reflections on the Bravo Egypt topic. I have found the informative sounds are taking longer response. Thanks a lot for being so good article! :)

Leave a Comment



Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below:


Treatise For The Seekers Of Guidance


Buy Now

Support Zaytuna

12000 Hearts Beating as One Can't Be Beat

donate now

The Ocean of "The Opening"

Taught by Imam Zaid Shakir

Learn More